Id go with Thorpe (and Rawson if available) but not Collin, he's as bad a Roo's but nailed to his line and kicks more. Also think young Ward from Spurs should be played not dropped forever a la Swift.

GlennMiller wrote:

---

If everyone is fit, and accepting that this will never happen, I'd like to see:

Buxton, Thorpe, Rawson, Mattock
Smallwood, Halford
Newell, Maguire
Derbyshire, JCH

Likely replacements:
D.Ward/Bowery, Frecklington,/White, Richardson.

The GK's a real problem. I'd probably stick with Roos if what SE says about Collin in training is correct. However, if Jim Funnell's fit, I'd take him!

---

 Id be happy with that side so long as the midfield arnt watchin the ball sail over their heads all game

Glen, can't see that realistically happening. If we adopt that formation at QPR it's game over. 

OK. So after all the flack that has been thrown around since the Preston performance, what advice would you all offer to SE regarding his team selection and tactics for QPR? The trouble with parking the bus is that our bus parks about 20 yards from our own goal and there's no respite. I'd personally like to see us play further up the field and defend by attacking. BTW, this red wine that Tesco have on offer at the moment is cracking!!

The central defence I'm still v unclear about.

Maguire I like but still seems unfit.

God dammit I still like green in there and halford type I still struggle with but hopeful.

I'd keep roos because Collin is not up to it either.

Keep Mattock and Buxton.

Stick with Collins and rawson.

Halford

Newall green smallwood maguire

Derbyshire.