Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
 

Topic: Stubbs - why is he still your manager?

Page 1 of 1  sorted by
Youth Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Date:

Stubbs - why is he still your manager?

Permalink  
 

I will upfront from the beginning - I am a Hearts supporter (and former resident of Rotherham) and some may say slightly biased. Since Stubbsy used to manage (??!!?) our 'friends' ****ebernian, over on the east side of Edinburgh, I continue to track the carnage the prat still creates. We Jambos are incredulous anybody with half a brain cell would offer Ehm Ehm Ehm Stubbsy a job. We are also gutted you stole our amusement from us - (1) we loved to watch the demise of Hibs before our eyes, (2) we used to crease ourselves with the utter drivel he used to come out with week after week after week and (3) the wild delusional predicitions preceding every game.  Despite having one of the top 6 largest budgets in Scottish football, whilst still in their 3rd season in The Chumpionship, they still flatter to deceive and 'HibsIt' every season.  Last season they totally flocked up getting promotion for the 2nd season on the trot - My cat could manage a football club better than that idiot.

Please listen to our advice and get rid of the guy now before he destroys the club - the legacy he has left the Leithiopians means they are still struggling in a one-horse race for the Diddy League this season.



__________________
ian
Club Legend
Status: Offline
Posts: 6218
Date:
Permalink  
 

I think it's too late for us.

There was ample warning in the skies.

The budget is gone
The window is closed
We will be bottom of the league at Christmas

The January sales!
Well be last in the queue
As burton max out their credit cards on basement bargains at the till.

Tony is stuck between a rock and a roll.
He loves ballads though I've heard.

He won't listen to you-to me, or the board, and the chuckle brothers aren't on the BBC anymore. He will muse over a whiskey and watch old tapes of Broadway as that famous ref from Rotherham joins in with 'I did it my Way'.



-- Edited by ian on Sunday 16th of October 2016 12:29:36 AM

__________________
Reserve Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 191
Date:
Permalink  
 
As much as i admire and appreciate TS for all hes done for us, he has dropped a massive ******* in choosing Stubbs. Get some experience in asap please!

__________________
Youth Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 9
Date:
Permalink  
 
I'm very sorry to hear that.

Despite getting the blind backing from the Hobos Board, and an increased players budget they could ill afford, he went about signing numerous players - none of them really shone or came close to the prophesies of Stubbs. Most stayed in the U20s or on the bench and in the end Stubbs resorted to getting a couple of emergency part-season loans from their kindred bretheren, Celtic. Liam Henderson & Stokesey did a job but they could never turn around the inadequecies for the rest of the squad. Most would argue Stokes didn't do much (didn't score many at all) but he did set others up.
Stubbs may be a nice person, he might have been an OK club player but he cannot get a team to gel, to add up to more than the sum parts and he is certainly clueless when it comes to knowing his strongest team/formation/tactics. The only thing he is undesputed World Champion is saying Ehm and talking utter nonesense to the press. For some reason they all lap it up and from the sounds of it so does your owners.

I wish you all well and hope you find someone decent to turn your fortunes around this season

__________________
First Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 893
Date:
Permalink  
 
For all you still supporting Stubbs, please see his latest media gaffe.

Secret to clean sheets? "Don't play one, two & three in league in last three games," says #rufc boss AS.

What the hell is that all about? Does that mean he's resigned to losing before we even step over the white line? If the manager is coming out with comments like that in public, then what effect is that having on his players. Shocking negativity. Oh and by the way, what was the excuse when we played the bottom clubs and we conceded, or the 5 we shipped against a league two side?

I'm absolutely livid with this, get shut Tony! Get him in the office first thing Monday morning and do the right thing. Anyone would be an improvement on Stubbs.

__________________
Vice-Captain
Status: Offline
Posts: 1000
Date:
Permalink  
 
They wouldn't be top if we had beaten them.

In terms of Stubbs I have seen nothing about him that impresses me. In terms of personality, skill set, motivational quality and tactical prowess I see 0 degrees Kelvin in fact I think the new name for absolute zero should be Alan Stubbs.

Now I don't mind losing football matches, or even relegation for that matter. What I do mind is how we do it. Love him or hate him when we lost under Evans you felt as if we shared the pain. With this guy I just feel contempt.

__________________
Vice-Captain
Status: Offline
Posts: 1118
Date:
Permalink  
 
Heman wrote:

They wouldn't be top if we had beaten them.

In terms of Stubbs I have seen nothing about him that impresses me. In terms of personality, skill set, motivational quality and tactical prowess I see 0 degrees Kelvin in fact I think the new name for absolute zero should be Alan Stubbs.

Now I don't mind losing football matches, or even relegation for that matter. What I do mind is how we do it. Love him or hate him when we lost under Evans you felt as if we shared the pain. With this guy I just feel contempt.


 agreed... and he always uses 'them' when referring to the players, not 'us'... he clearly sees this as just a job, with no emotional commitment to being 'Rotherham' or part & parcel of the club that we all call 'ours'..... 4 games to turn it around or he is surely gone...



__________________
First Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 618
Date:
Permalink  
 
S8Miller wrote:

For all you still supporting Stubbs, please see his latest media gaffe.

Secret to clean sheets? "Don't play one, two & three in league in last three games," says #rufc boss AS.

What the hell is that all about? Does that mean he's resigned to losing before we even step over the white line? If the manager is coming out with comments like that in public, then what effect is that having on his players. Shocking negativity. Oh and by the way, what was the excuse when we played the bottom clubs and we conceded, or the 5 we shipped against a league two side?

I'm absolutely livid with this, get shut Tony! Get him in the office first thing Monday morning and do the right thing. Anyone would be an improvement on Stubbs.


 Agreed, disgraceful comment for a football manager to make.



__________________
First Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 618
Date:
Permalink  
 
I wouldn't wait 4 games. I'd sack him now.

Then again, I would have sacked him 4 games ago when it was clear for all to see that he was totally clueless.

__________________
First Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 802
Date:
Permalink  
 
I'd have sacked him after Morecambe. The writing was already on the wall

__________________
Reserve Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 121
Date:
Permalink  
 
I have to agree I have seen the senario a few times in my Millers time. From the players, to the fans even the coaching staff. He is not for the Millers he cannot relate to anything or anyone. TIME TO GO............ NOW. For over 55 years I have given my support, thick or thin my Mr Stubbs you are the worst manager I have seen and by god we have had some bad ones. I m now a pensioner and do I want to find the money to watch my team. Many times I have said this over the years but I am afraid enough is enough. If my team and their manager cannot give me some sign of commitment WHY THE HELL SHOULD I FIND THE CASH TO SUPPORT THEM. Tony over to you

__________________
Vice-Captain
Status: Offline
Posts: 1118
Date:
Permalink  
 
oneaday wrote:

I wouldn't wait 4 games. I'd sack him now.

Then again, I would have sacked him 4 games ago when it was clear for all to see that he was totally clueless.


I'd be happy enough if he went now too, but after the next 4 games, against teams we have to take points off if we are to hold any chance... if we don't pick up points in those, he has no excuses left.

He's thinks we are improving, and he thinks we couldn't expect to get any points from the 'top three' in our last three games. 4 more games without picking up 4 to 6 points and all his reasoning is shot and I'd be very very surprised if TS doesn't step in.

So he has that long I reckon, and I'd love it to turn around and see us start winning, none of us can see it happening though. For the record, I've nothing against Stubbs, I don't think any of us do - we are Millers, just that.



__________________
Reserve Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 121
Date:
Permalink  
 
I am afraid the longer TS leaves it then the worse it will be. It will get to the stage where the fans will not attend or even take to voicing their opinions. "PURSHOUSE OUT" still sits in my ear. "BOOTH OUT" another. Plus ones directed at past managers (Scott, Begarra etc). Do you really want to go down that route Tony.

__________________
Reserve Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 121
Date:
Permalink  
 
Tony most of us Millers are hurting, the kind of hurt we have not felt since the dark days of Millmoor and Don Valley, please, please, please act NOW

__________________
Vice-Captain
Status: Offline
Posts: 1780
Date:
Permalink  
 
Does TS read this board?

__________________
ian
Club Legend
Status: Offline
Posts: 6218
Date:
Permalink  
 
Rotherbird wrote:

I am afraid the longer TS leaves it then the worse it will be. It will get to the stage where the fans will not attend or even take to voicing their opinions. "PURSHOUSE OUT" still sits in my ear. "BOOTH OUT" another. Plus ones directed at past managers (Scott, Begarra etc). Do you really want to go down that route Tony.


 This is nowhere near the cir***stances of those dark days Rotherbird. 

 

We have all we need for a vibrant successful club . Indeed we are pretty vibrant and successful but for this awful start.

 

If and when it's up to the fans to keep on keeping in. 



__________________
Reserve Team
Status: Offline
Posts: 121
Date:
Permalink  
 
Ian I was talking managerial and ownership senarios not financial. TS was and is our savior finance wise.

__________________
Moderator
Status: Offline
Posts: 2408
Date:
Permalink  
 
The 1st, 2nd, 3rd comment is indeed, yet another PR disaster from Stubbs. I've had high level coaches mention a couple of times this weekend about 'luck' and 'mistakes'. It seems to me in the coaching world, luck and individual errors are the product of bad coaching. Lets not forget these are highly skilled, highly conditioned individuals that have been used to resources and coaching conditions that don't appear in our real world.

A good manager aligns his staff to work best in the market they operate, using the skills they bring to the team to complement each other - in any profession. That's how the sum of parts becomes greater to over achieve. I would like to see statistical analysis of how the assumption that improvements are being made, because the view of one person, is not acceptable or believable.

He's not the first to fail in trying to acquire more akin Championship players. So did Redfearn, and so did RM in the season we were relegated and look how that ended up. Indeed we got here, not by footballing teams to death but bludgeoning teams to death. In my lifetime, there's only one squad I can remember were better 'footballing' and that was when we won Div4 - 1 team, one season in 30+ years.

In my eyes Stubbs has ripped the identity of the club out, and granted this hasn't been helped by the awful lack of long term planning by Evans, the debacle of Redfearn and the dangle tactics of Warnock - but he and those above him have to shoulder the blame. Ultimately it will be Stubbs that comes off worst, but the problems of our club start higher up than that and until that is addressed with the right funding, right personnel and resources we will never ever be a Championship club, and as for a sustainable one - pink fluffy unicorns riding on rainbows springs to mind.

__________________

FA Licensed Coach & Referee

 

ian
Club Legend
Status: Offline
Posts: 6218
Date:
Permalink  
 

Stubbs clearly does not have that charismatic gift that gets instant results. The question the chairman is constantly struggling with is long V short term commitment.

It is not a straightforward decision. I would have sacked him after 4 matches but the longer he is here the more difficult it actually becomes as more factors come into focus.

Now Blackstock is fit
Before we had injuries
Before we had new players
Now broadfoot is back
Maybe the issues are so deep we need to go back before we go forward.

We couldn't back Evans the way he wanted to do it.

We couldn't keep warnock 

Etc etc .

 

Given our status this is no longer as straightforward as it seems 

 

 

I'm really for sticking as the club needs to learn lessons. Those lessons cannot be learned by quick fixes anymore. 



-- Edited by ian on Sunday 16th of October 2016 10:32:47 PM

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.